Pain in Pawhuska

1Small Town Secrets

42 minAug 4, 2018

Kelly and Steve head to Wisconsin to investigate a homicide; the case becomes personal after they receive a letter from the victim’s daughters; their search uncovers a town’s dark side, crimes against children and lies within a church.

2The Professors End

42 minAug 12, 2018

Kelly and Tonya investigate the strange death of a retired college professor in Tonya’s home town, whose cremation was halted by an anonymous tip call hinting at murder; an autopsy proves the tipster’s information is accurate.

3Holding Onto Hope

42 minAug 18, 2018

Kelly and Johnny return to their home state of Texas to look into the disappearance of a young mother in 2000, whose family has never given up on her; while some suspect murder, others claim to have seen her on the run with a mystery man.

4Down By the Lake

42 minAug 25, 2018

Ruled accidental, Kelly and Johnny Bonds look into the 2011 drowning death of 19-year-old Blayne Davis, whose mother suspects foul play.

5Danger at Dawn

42 minSep 1, 2018

Kelly and Abbey investigate the cold-blooded murder of a fun-loving Texas country boy shot in the back of his head; it could the result of a love triangle gone tragically wrong.

6Preacher's Mother

42 minSep 8, 2018

Kelly and Steve investigate the brutal slaying of beloved mother Eloise Payne, who was stabbed 38 times in her Michigan home; a mysterious car spotted in the area may hold the key to identifying her killer.

7No Safe Return

42 minSep 15, 2018

Kelly and Aaron Sam look into the disappearance of a father who tragically vanished just before he could move back home to his family; they ask if a financial windfall could have had something to do with the man's disappearance.

8Bound and Burnt

42 minSep 22, 2018

Kelly and Johnny investigate the twisted murder of a new grandmother who was strangled and set on fire in an abandoned school bus; things get personal when the primary suspects turn out to be Kelly's neighbors.

9Pain in Pawhuska

42 minSep 30, 2018Now viewing

Kelly and Steve investigate the brutal slaying of an Oklahoma teenager whose night of cruising and partying turned deadly. Could a scandalous town rumor have led to her death? The team searches for justice 22 years later.

10The Case Behind the Billboards

42 minOct 6, 2018

Kelly and Johnny uncover new details in the tragic 27-year-old unsolved murder of Kathy Page, a case that shocked a small town and inspired the award winning film “Three Billboards Outside Ebbing, Missouri.”

11Death Among Him, Part 1 (Carbon County, WY)

42 minFeb 16, 2019

Kelly and Tonya head to Wyoming to work with Carbon County Law Enforcement to look into the mysterious deaths of two women years apart, but connected by the same circle of friends.

12Death Among Him, Part 2 (Carbon County, WY)

42 minFeb 23, 2019

In part two of their investigation, the Cold Justice team continues to investigate three mysterious deaths in Wyoming, hoping they will be able to finally give answers to all the families involved.

13Backwater Bloodshed (Concordia Parish, LA)

42 minMar 2, 2019

Kelly and Steve head into Louisiana to work with the Concordia Parish Sheriff's Office and investigate the 2016 homicide of a 26-year-old whose body was found on the banks of the bayou. Can the team finally bring justice to his grieving family?

14Golden Years Gone (Prowers County, CO)

42 minMar 9, 2019

Kelly and Abbey head to Colorado to help the Prowers County Sheriff's Office investigate the 1991 homicide of a beloved elderly couple who were brutally killed while working at their local VFW Hall.

15A Mother's Dying Wish (Hernando County, FL)

42 minMar 16, 2019

Kelly and Steve return to Hernando County, FL, to help look into the two decades old homicide of a 21-year-old woman who disappeared after a late night party, and her body was discovered years later in a nearby orange grove.

16Texas Tragedy

42 minMar 23, 2019

The Jasper County Sheriff's Department assist Kelly and Johnny as they sort through family drama and doomsday rumors to help a daughter unravel the mystery surrounding the 2012 disappearance of her 56-year-old mother.

17Family Betrayal (Idaho Falls, ID)

42 minMar 30, 2019

Kelly travels to Abbey's home state to work with the Idaho Falls PD to help investigate the 2007 homicide of a young mother. When her body was discovered almost 3 years later outside the city, it left a family searching for her killer.

18Horror In The Home (Amarillo, TX)

42 minApr 6, 2019

Kelly and Steve work with the Potter County Sheriff's Department in Amarillo, TX, in investigating the brutal murder of a doting mother of four. Will DNA testing help them find the murderer and answers for her grieving kids?

19Valentine's Day Violence

42 minMar 14, 2020

Kelly and Tonya investigate the 2016 murder of Heyzel Obando, a young Florida mother shot to death in her own home. It’ll take cutting-edge forensic technology and old-school interrogation techniques to catch her killer and bring justice to her grieving mother.

20Small Town Predator

42 minMar 21, 2020

Kelly and Johnny team up to tackle the 1988 murder of Cindi Smith whose headless body was found at a cemetery after a night at a local bar. The patrons of the bar could hold the key to identifying her killer and getting her family justice.

21Mystery on the Mountain

42 minMar 28, 2020

Kelly and Abbey investigate the 2012 disappearance of Brian Shookman, a young father who was traveling to Idaho to attend a family reunion, but never showed up. As the list of suspects grows, can the team uncover the truth behind his vanishing?

22Double Life Discovered

42 minApr 4, 2020

Kelly and Johnny investigate one of their oldest cases ever -- the brutal 1984 murder of Johnnie Albritton, an elderly store owner in Texas known for having a wife with a violent temper. Was his death the robbery gone wrong it appeared to be, or a plot of his wife’s design?

23Digging For Answers

42 minApr 11, 2020

Kelly and Steve head to Oregon to help solve the 1993 murder of a young man allegedly shot and buried by a group of dangerous criminals. They'll need to pit them against each other to crack the case and finally bring justice to his family.

24Deadly Affairs

42 minApr 18, 2020

Kelly and Steve investigate the 2016 homicide of Stacey Devine, a hard-working mother who was strangled to death and dumped in a ditch. Was it a random act of violence, or did her strained marriage factor in to her murder?

25A Family's Nightmare

42 minApr 25, 2020

Kelly and Abbey search for new clues in the fatal shooting of a mother of six that was initially considered suicide. Their investigation exposes a heart-breaking trail of secrets hidden for 25 years.

26Fatal Betrayal (Fort Myers, FL)

42 minMay 2, 2020

Kelly and Abbey return to Fort Myers, FL, to tackle the 1997 murder of Keith Jones, an aspiring police officer mugged and shot in his motel room; multiple suspects include a female witness that may have set him up.